These easy Oreo ice cream sandwiches are my new favorite dessert! Scoops of ice cream stuffed in between Oreos and rolled in toppings is all it takes to get your chocolate fix! And, and and! A video for these babies down below! High fives all around.
Well, I found my latest obsession.
And it’s fantastic.
Ice Cream. Oreos. Toppings.
If these weren’t already America’s favorite cookie, they would be now. Plus, I’m pretty sure they’re now ice cream’s favorite cookie. After this Chocolate Peanut Butter Oreo Cake and Cookies and Cream Oreo Cake, we definitely know they’re cake’s favorite cookie as well.
Gym membership that I cancelled years ago? I might be coming for you now with all this Oreo love going around.
These little pieces of joy are inspired by Klondike’s Oreo Ice Cream Sandwiches, which are, in one word, amazing.
But, while I may be biased, I’m a bit more partial to these homemade ones for two reasons:
1. I can customize it with any ice cream I want, including Toasted Marshmallow Ice Cream, Homemade Strawberry Ice Cream, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Ice Cream,
and, most importantly,
2. These can be made whenever the Oreo/ice cream craving hits (it happens more than I care to admit).
Now, there is one crucial element to making these ice cream sandwiches:
Double Stuf Oreos.
From experience, let me tell you, the regular Oreos are pretty flimsy. In fact, the most recent batch I bought were so flimsy that, not only did I have to do a double take to see if there was even filling inside, I couldn’t split any apart without them cracking.
Now I love Oreos–a lot–but I do feel like they gyp you a whole lot with the regular Oreos.
Okay, so there might be two crucial elements here. If you aren’t feeling the Double Stuf, then I’m going to suggest using those fantastic Oreo Thins.
Why? Well, as you can see in the video below, if you use the Thins, you can actually use two cookies per ice cream sandwich. The Thins are actually a little too ‘thin’ to split, so I like to use them whole. Plus, I get double the cookie and filling that way.
That probably totally defeats the purpose of the Oreo being thin, but it’s not like Ice Cream Stuffed Oreos were going to be healthy anyway… 😉
Oh yeah, these are totally ice cream’s favorite cookie.
- 12 Oreos or 24 Oreo Thins
- 12 scoops of ice cream [homemade: https://www.alattefood.com/recipes/frozen-treats/] or store-bought
- Mini Chocolate Chips
- Sprinkles
- Toffee Bits
- Mint Chips
- Anything Your Heart Desires!
- Twist and pull Oreos apart. If using Oreo Thins, you can skip this step (as shown in video above)
- Spoon about 1 Tbsp of ice cream onto one side of the Oreos.
- Place the remaining Oreos on top of the ice cream and slightly press Oreo into the ice cream.
- Roll the sandwiches in your toppings.
- Enjoy!
- Freeze leftovers.
Here are some other fun recipes you might love:
Meg @ With Salt and Wit says
And I thought dunking oreo’s in milk was the best way to eat them!
Bintu | Recipes from a Pantry says
Holy cow…WHY have I never tried this before?! These look amazing!
Medha @ Whisk & Shout says
What a great idea- gotta try 🙂
Anna @ Crunchy Creamy Sweet says
My kids will have a ton of fun making these Oreo sandwiches! So yummy!
Des @ Lifes Ambrosia says
It doesn’t get any easier, or better, than this when it comes to ice cream sandwiches. What a great idea!
Sabrina says
I love the variety! My kids would gobble these up!
michelle @ blackberry babe says
Oh boy. I think you’ve just created my husband’s dream dessert! Ice cream and Oreos, yep!
[email protected] Complete Savorist says
Now this is kicking the Oreo love up a notch.
Mary @ LOVE the secret ingredient says
Such a simple way to make something different and exciting, very cute